Rusty Nail
A simple cocktail with Scotch whisky and Drambuie, delivering a smooth, sweet, and smoky flavor.
What is this drink?
The Rusty Nail is a two-ingredient Scottish classic that reached the height of its popularity in the Rat Pack era of the 1960s. It combines Scotch whisky and Drambuie — a honey, herb, and spice-infused Scotch-based liqueur — stirred simply over ice for a drink that is warming, complex, and effortlessly sophisticated.
Why you'll love it
You only need two ingredients, yet the flavor is remarkably layered. Drambuie adds honey sweetness, heather, and spice while the Scotch provides smoky depth. Together they create a warming sipper that feels luxurious without any fuss.
When to serve
Ideal as a nightcap or after-dinner drink on a cold evening. It pairs naturally with nuts, dark chocolate, and aged cheeses. Serve it during the holiday season or anytime you want something stiff, smooth, and soul-warming.
Pro tip
The ratio matters — a 2:1 Scotch to Drambuie ratio keeps it spirit-forward without becoming cloying. Use a large ice cube to control dilution. A blended Scotch works beautifully, but if you want to explore, try an Islay malt for a smoky, peaty version.
Scotch Whisky
The primary spirit — smoky, malty, and warming. Choose a quality blended Scotch like Dewar's or Johnnie Walker Black for smoothness, or a peated single malt if you enjoy bold smoke.
Drambuie
A Scottish liqueur made from aged Scotch, heather honey, herbs, and spices. It is the soul of the Rusty Nail, adding sweetness, floral notes, and herbal complexity.
Lemon Twist
The garnish is optional but the citrus oils expressed from a lemon peel brighten the nose of the drink and add a subtle aromatic contrast to the rich, warm base.
Swap Options
Use Glayva instead of Drambuie for a citrus-forward, spiced alternative. For a sweeter style, increase the Drambuie ratio to 1:1. Add a single dash of Angostura bitters to introduce a herbal, bitter edge that cuts through the sweetness.
Combine ingredients
Add Scotch and Drambuie to a rocks glass with ice.
Tips:
- •Use a large ice cube to slow dilution.
Stir gently
Stir to combine flavors.
Tips:
- •Do not over-stir to maintain balance.
Garnish
Add a lemon twist for aroma.
Tips:
- •Twist over glass to release oils.
- Adjust sweetness with Drambuie quantity.
- Serve over large ice for slower dilution.
- Use quality Scotch for best flavor.
Different ways to make this drink your own
Glayva Nail
Replace Drambuie with Glayva for a citrus-forward, slightly sweeter variation. Glayva is a Scottish liqueur with orange peel and spice notes that lend the Rusty Nail a brighter, more aromatic character. It's an excellent alternative for those who find Drambuie slightly too honeyed and wish for more citrus lift.
Smoky Rusty Nail
Use a heavily peated Islay Scotch — such as Laphroaig or Ardbeg — as the base spirit for a dramatically smokier, more intense version. The iodine and campfire smoke of an Islay malt creates a fascinating counterpoint to Drambuie's floral honey sweetness, producing a cocktail with real depth and intrigue.
Bitters Rusty Nail
Add a single dash of Angostura bitters to the standard recipe for a variation with herbal complexity and a drier finish. The bitters introduce aromatic bittering agents that cut the sweetness of the Drambuie slightly and add a subtle spiced quality that makes the cocktail feel more sophisticated.
Tools that make this drink come together
Mixing Glass
The Rusty Nail is a stirred cocktail — never shaken. A mixing glass allows you to combine Scotch and Drambuie with ice and stir gently to achieve the perfect dilution and temperature without the cloudiness that shaking introduces. Forty slow rotations is the target.
Bar Spoon
A long-handled bar spoon with a twisted handle allows smooth, controlled stirring that gently dilutes and chills the spirits without over-aerating them. The twisted handle naturally guides the circular stirring motion that mixes the two components evenly without splashing.
Julep Strainer
Used with the mixing glass to strain the stirred cocktail into a rocks glass over ice. Unlike a Hawthorne strainer, the julep strainer sits flat inside the mixing glass and holds back ice whilst allowing the chilled, diluted cocktail to flow through cleanly.
Can't Find These?
No mixing glass? A large measuring jug works well — it's wide enough for a bar spoon and stable during stirring. A slotted spoon or even a long fork can substitute for a bar spoon. A regular tea strainer holds back ice if no julep strainer is available.
The right glass makes a real difference
Rocks Glass (Old-Fashioned Glass)
The Rusty Nail belongs in a chunky, wide-mouthed rocks glass — sometimes called an old-fashioned glass or lowball. The wide base accommodates a large single ice cube or sphere that melts slowly, providing gradual dilution over the course of drinking. The low profile keeps the cocktail's modest volume looking properly filled, and the heavy glass feels appropriately substantial for such a bold, spirit-forward drink.
Alternatives
A stemless wine glass is a perfectly acceptable substitute if no rocks glass is available. Some prefer a traditional Glencairn whisky glass for a more refined, nosing-focused experience — this works particularly well if you reduce the ice and sip the drink more slowly. A short tumbler of any kind will do in an informal setting.
Perfect food pairings to complete the experience
Smoked Almonds and Pecans
Smoky, salted nuts are the simplest and most perfect accompaniment to the Rusty Nail. The salt enhances the sweetness of the Drambuie, the smoke echoes the Scotch's character, and the fat of the nuts coats the palate between sips in the most satisfying way.
Aged Cheddar and Oatcakes
A strong aged Cheddar or a crumbly Orkney Cheddar on traditional Scottish oatcakes is a classically appropriate pairing. The sharpness of the cheese cuts the sweetness of the Drambuie beautifully, and the oat biscuit texture complements the earthy warmth of the Scotch.
Honey-Glazed Pigs in Blankets
Sticky, honey-glazed chipolatas wrapped in crispy streaky bacon echo the honey notes of the Drambuie whilst providing savoury, meaty richness that anchors the cocktail. They're a crowd-pleasing option that works well at parties and requires minimal effort.
Dark Chocolate Shortbread
Buttery Scottish shortbread dipped in dark chocolate is a sophisticated pairing that complements the Drambuie's sweetness without overpowering it. The bitter chocolate creates a pleasing contrast to the honey-and-heather liqueur, and the buttery shortbread adds an appropriately Scottish character.
Prep in advance for effortless serving
Pre-Batch the Cocktail
Combine Scotch and Drambuie in the correct ratio in a sealed bottle and store at room temperature. A pre-batched Rusty Nail can be poured directly over ice in a rocks glass without any additional mixing. This is ideal for casual entertaining where consistency and speed of service matter more than ceremony.
Prepare Large Ice Cubes
Freeze large single ice cubes or ice spheres in advance using a silicone mould — they melt significantly more slowly than standard cubes, providing minimal dilution and a long, slow cold drink. Prepare them 24 hours ahead to ensure they're fully frozen and crystal clear.
Chill the Mixing Glass
Fill the mixing glass with ice and cold water 10 minutes before using, then empty it before adding the cocktail ingredients. A pre-chilled mixing glass keeps the drink cooler during stirring and reduces the amount of melt needed to reach the right temperature, producing a less diluted, more concentrated final drink.
Set Up a Scotch Station
Arrange the Scotch bottle, Drambuie, rocks glass, and ice in one place before guests arrive. The Rusty Nail requires no juicing, shaking, or complex equipment — a pre-organised station allows you to pour drinks confidently and quickly without hunting for ingredients during the event.
Common questions answered by our bartenders
Be the first to review this recipe!
Got Leftovers?
Turn what you already have in your fridge into delicious meals. Our AI-powered generator creates personalized recipes from your ingredients.
Browse more like this:
You Might Also Like
Discover more delicious drinks similar to what you're viewing
